|
 |
| CLINICAL RESEARCH |
|
| Year : 2010 | Volume
: 31
| Issue : 3 | Page : 351-354 |
|
|
Comparative study of Upavasa and Upavasa with Pachana in the management of Agnisada
Ami Rajani, Mahesh Kumar Vyas, Hitesh A Vyas
Department of Basic Principles, Institute for Post Graduate Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Gujarat Ayurved University, Jamnagar, Gujarat, India
| Date of Web Publication | 26-Feb-2011 |
Correspondence Address:
Ami Rajani
Chaitanya, 32, Shiv Srishti Society, Behind IOC quarters, Opp. Rani Tower, Kalawad Road, Rajkot
India
 Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None  | Check |
DOI: 10.4103/0974-8520.77166
 Abstract | | |
Ayurvedic management is not only concerned with the cure of the diseased person, but is also meant to maintain the health of the healthy person because it is used for Dhatusamya. Langhana is the prime tool in the process of Dhatusamya. In this research study, Upavasa plus Pachana and Upavasa (among ten types of Langhanas) are applied in two different groups, using the random sampling method. Upavasa is taken as Hina Matra Bhojana - that is, gradually increasing the dose of Ahara (by Padanshika Krama) was applied on the basis of the Ahara Shakti of the Atura and status of the Agnisada. Furthermore, for the Pachana, Shunthi (Zingiber officinale) was selected. The subjects for the study were patients who had signs and symptoms of Agnisada and were between the age group of 20 and 60 years. In Group A (Upavasa plus Pachana) 83.77% and in Group B (Upavasa) 72.97% improvement was found, which was statistically highly significant (< 0.001). Upavasa plus Pachana and Upavasa were both found beneficial in promoting the Agni in patients with Agnisada. However, in the percentage-wise comparison Group A showed better result than Group B. Keywords: Langhana, Upavasa, Hinamatra Bhojana, Padamshika Krama
How to cite this article:
Rajani A, Vyas MK, Vyas HA. Comparative study of Upavasa and Upavasa with Pachana in the management of Agnisada. AYU 2010;31:351-4 |
| Introduction | |  |
Every science has its own principles and these principles could not have been made up at once. The principles of Ayurveda are based on strict experimental studies of several years and are the outcome of those studies. Several Acharyas have tested these principles for many years and only after that they have been placed in the Samhitas. This process is needed for the establishment of the applied aspect of Ayurveda in the modern era.
Agni is the primary and most important component of the body. Any transformation in the body cannot occur without it. In the condition of the cessation of Agni one dies. [1] Jathragnimandya is an abnormal status of the Annavaha Srotasa, which is the initial condition of any disorder, and it is an accepted fact by all the writers that Agnimandya forms an integral part in the pathogenesis of each and every disease. [2] The definition of Agnimandya could be understood as the inhibited activity of the Pachakagni resulting in delayed or partial digestion or indigestion of food taken even in small measures at proper intervals and by the production of Ama and abnormal Lakshana related to the Mahasrotasa and having a tendency to affect the Rogamarga. Many synonyms were described in the Samhitas for Agnimandya, which are, Agnisada, Durbalagni, Agnivadha, Hatanala, Agninasha, and so on. Here, in this particular study, the Agnisada is taken among these synonyms. As per the dictionary meaning, Sada means sinking down / exhaustion / decay / loss. Hence, the meaning of Agnisada is exhaustion of Agni and the like. No direct reference had been found for the Nidanas of Agnisada, but the Nidana of Asamyaka Pachana of the Ahara, which is given by Acharya Kashyapa, [3] can be taken as the Nidana of Agnisada.
For the assessment of the status of Agnisada a special proforma was designed, wherein, the Abhyavaharana Shakti and Jarana Shakti of each individual patient were analyzed. For the Abhyavaharana Shakti the Sarvagraha and Parigraha Ahara Matra of the patients were calculated and for the Jarana Shakti the symptoms of the Jirna Ahara Lakshana, given by Acharya Shusruta in Swasthvritta Adhyaya of Uttarasthan, were taken as the criteria for assessment.
Ahara is stated to be a Karana of the Sharira as well as Roga; [4] hence, the treatment could also be with Ahara. He management of diseases in Ayurveda starts with the Nidana Parivarjana. In the Ayurvedic text, Langhana is stated to be the best treatment for Santarpanotha Vyadhi. Here, Langhana has been described under a broad aspect, and ten treatment modalities have been grouped under this umbrella. The definition of the Langhana is given as that which causes lightness of the body. [5] Here the Upavasa and Pachana types of Langhanas were compared by the scholar to understand the efficacy of both in the Agnisada. Upavasa may be full or partial, it also means Ek kala Bhojana or Hina Matra bhojana and so forth.
Here, in this research article, Hina Matra Bhojana is taken as Langhana. As Acharya Sushruta mentioned, in the patient with Mandagni, it is best to take Ahara that is less in quantity. [6] A special schedule for seven days was prepared for this study; and for these seven days, the Padanshikakrama[7] (gradual increase of the quantity of the Ahara) was applied. The results were evaluated, as per data found.
| Aims and Objectives | | |
- To evaluate the efficacy of the Langhana Upakrama on the Digestive disorder, especially Agnisada.
- To compare the efficacy of Upavasa and Upavasa along with Pachana in the management of Agnisada.
| Materials and Methods | | |
Conceptual material
- For the conceptual study, various texts and journals had been referred.
Clinical material
- Patients having classical signs and symptoms of Agnisada were selected from the inpatient department (IPD) and outpatient department (OPD) of the Basic Principles Department of I.P.G.T. and R.A., Jamnagar.
- To assess the status of Agnisada, a specific research Proforma was developed on the basis of Abhyavaharana Shakti and Jarana Shakti.
Criteria for selection of patients
Patients between the age of 20 and 60 years, having classical symptoms of Agnisada, were selected.
Criteria for exclusion of the patients
- Patients below 20 and above 60 years were excluded.
- Patients with chronic debilitating diseases such as Rajayakshama, Madhumeha, hypertension, genetic disorders, and other acute systemic disorders had been excluded.
Design of Groups and Management
The diet schedule given to the patients during treatment, where Matra of the Ahara was increased, was given for seven days. The patients were advised to fast on the first day and for next three meals, including lunch and dinner, one-fourth of this diet was given. For the next three meals half of the diet was given and for the three meals following, three-fourth of the diet was given. After this the following three meals consisted of the full diet.
Criteria of assessment
Total assessment criteria as per reduction in Vyadhi bala, Samyaka Agni Deepana, and Improvement in Atura Bala:
- Cure 100%
- Mild improvement > 75%
- Moderate improvement > 50%
- Improvement > 25%
- Unchanged < 25%
The information gathered on the basis of the above-mentioned observations was subjected to statistical analysis in terms of mean (x), standard deviation (S.D.) and standard error (S.E.). The paired 't' test was carried out at P < 0.05, P < 0.01, and P < 0.001 levels. The obtained results were interpreted as:
| Observations | | |
A total of 59 patients were registered. In group A, 30 patients completed the treatment, while four patients Left Against Medical Advice (LAMA). In group B, 25 patients completed the treatment, while one patient LAMA. Among the 54 patients, 44.07 % were from the age group of 30 to 39 years. Adhyashana (55%), Vishamashana (36.67%), Samashana (30%), Amatravata Bhojana (50.85%), Irregular dietary habit (71.19%), habit of water intake after meal (83.05%), and Atanmana Bhunjitam (61.01%) were reported by the patients. In the Sharirika Prakriti-wise distribution, the maximum number of patients, that is, 25.42% had Vata - Kapha Prakriti.
In the Nidana-wise distribution, AtiGuru Bhojana was (47.46%); while Atibhojana and Atisnigdha Bhojana was found to be 50.85 and 40.86%, respectively. In the Vihara-wise distribution 55.93% patients had the habit of Divaswapa and 44.07% had the habit of Ratri Jagarana. In the Manasika Nidana-wise distribution Chinta was found in 69.49% of patients.
In the Lakshana-wise distribution, decreased Abhyavaharana Shakti was found in all the patients, a decrease in Kshudha, Klama Parigamana, and Kukshi Shaithilya was found in 94.91, 88.14, and 83.05%, respectively. Decrease in Utsaha was found in 81.35% of the patients. Asamyaka Mala Pravritti was found in 81.35% of the patients. Among them thrice the Mala Pravritti and twice the Mala Pravritti was found in 16.95 and 23.73%, respectively. Ayathakala Mala Pravritti was found in 21.81% of the patients. However, a decrease in Annashraddha and Deha Laghuta was found in 76.27 and 72.88%. Asamyaka Udgara, Vata, and Mura Pravritti were found in 61.02, 57.63, and 45.76%, respectively. Chronicity of one to two months of the Vyadhi was found in 55.93% and a duration of 15 to 30 days was found in 45.76%.
Effect of therapy on Lakshanas
The effect of therapy on various lakshanas is shown in [Figure 1](a) & (b). [Table 1] shows that in the percentage-wise comparison of Group A and Group B, Group A showed better results than Group B. However, the 't' value of Group B was greater than that of Group A. | Figure 1a: Effect of therapy on Lakshanas
Figure 1b: Effect of therapy on Lakshanas
Click here to view |
| Discussion | | |
Observations
The maximum number of patients, that is, 50.85% were taking Amatravata Ahara, which is called as "Sarvadosha Prakopaka0"; [12] Adhyashana(55%), Vishamashana (36.67%) Samashana (30%) was found. According to Sushrutacharya these three are "Bahuvyadhikaraka." [13]
The maximum number of patients (25.42%) had a Vata-Kapha Prakriti, and it was already mentioned in the Charaka Samhita, that the Doshas that are dominant in the formation of the Prakriti are more prone to vitiate immediately, than others. [14] Hence, the vitiation of Vata leads to Agnivaishamya and the vitiation of Kapha leads to Agnisada.
The maximum number of the patients (83.05%), had a habit of water intake after meal, which is "Kapha Prada" as per Acharya Bhava Prakasha, [15] which further leads to the vitiation of Agni.
The maximum number of patients had done Diwaswapa (55.93%) in their routine life. Divaswapa is Kapha Prakopaka, while Ratrijagaran0a increases the Vata, which is the main cause of Agnivaismya, which may lead to Agnisada.
In the present study Ayathakala Mala Pravritti was found in 28.81%, which showed that the vitiated Agni directly affected the time period in which the Mala formation occurs. Mala Pravritti (23.73%) two to three times and more than three times (16.95%) indicates that in Agnisada the function of normal Agni, that is, Sara and Kitta Vivecana is vitiated, due to which the proper Matra of the Mala is not excreted at one time, hence, Muhura - Muhura Mala Pravritti occurs. Constipation is found in 8.47% of the patients and is due to Krura Kostha (8.33%).
Both the groups statistically show highly significant results of Mala Pravritti, but Group A (80.76%) shows a better result than Group B (67.65%). Shunthi is said to be Grahi as well as Vibandhanuta. When the Mala Pravritti is more than two to three times, Shunthi being Agni dominant, it absorbs the excess Apyamsha. As a result it binds the Mala, which has excess fluid and gives the Grahi effect, and act as a Vibandhanuta, due to its Prabhava. [16]
In a percentage-wise comparison of both the groups, group A showed better result than group B, but the 't' value of Group B is greater than that of Group A. This is because the number of patients is not equal in both the groups.
In a percentage-wise comparison of both the groups, group A shows a better result than group B, the reason behind it is that in group A, the effect of Deepana (due to Langhana) and Pachana (due to Shunthi) are both present, while group B mainly has the Deepana (due to Langhana). In Group B only Upavasa is advised, whereas, in Group A Upavasa plus Pachana is advised. In both the Groups, an increasing quantity of food was given. Hence, a highly significant result was found in both the groups.
Mode of action of the Upavasa
Mode of action of the Upavasa can be understood in this manner: If Agni does not get fuel in the form of food, it starts digesting Dosha. Agni for its existence needs a constant feed of fuel. As a routine the food serves as the fuel. In the absence of food, in the preliminary stage Agni uses Dosha as fuel. [8] This special property of Agni is used as a treatment modality. The mode of action of the Upavasa can also be understood with the help of modern science. If the consumption of the glucose is decreased, the glycogen, then fat, and in the last stage, protein, is broken down for the supply of glucose to the tissue, which is similar to the view of Ayurveda.
Acharya Vagbhata has mentioned that Langhana
- Decreases the Doshas
- Increases the Agni
Hence it increases the Swasthya, Kshudha,Trishna, Ruchi, Agnibala, and Oja.[9]
Padamshika Krama
Food taken in optimum quantity is termed as Matravat. Ayurveda believes that every human being is unique and different from others; hence the needs for everything are different from one to another. The hunger or the quantity of food needed also differs from one person to another. Therefore, it is not possible to decide a specific quantity of food that will be applicable to all. Besides the Prakriti of human beings, the nature of food items is also variable. Hence, the study of the Schedule of Aharamatra is prepared according to the capacity of food intake of an individual.
Why the Padamshika Krama? Here, in this research study, the increasing method of food was applied. The reason behind this is that by gradually decreasing the Apathya and gradually increasing the Pathya, the Apathya can be completely stopped, due to which the recurrence of the vitiated Doshas is avoided, and the good properties thus inculcated are sustained for a long time. [10]
Mode of action of the Shunthi
Shunthi is described in both Deepaniya and Pachaniya Gana; A Panchana Dravya performs the digestion of the Ahara, but does not increase the Agni. [11] In Agnisada, Ama (undigested food) is formed. Shunthi enters in this Ama and creates Akasha to make a path for Agni to enter and perform its function.
| Conclusion | | |
Drugs that stimulate the digestive power are dominant in Agni and Vayu Mahabhutas. Taking into consideration the total effect of therapy, Group A showed better result than Group B. Hence, it is concluded that the combined Langhana therapy, that is, Upavasa and Pachana, shows a better result than Upavasa only.
| References | | |
| 1. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Chakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5th ed. Chikitsasthana. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 512. 
|
| 2. | Ashtang Hridaya with the commentaries, Sarvangasundara ofArundatta and Ayurveda Rasayana of Hemadri. Sastri HS, editor. 9 th ed. NidanaSthana. Paradakara Bhisagacarya., Varanasi: Chaukhamba Orientalia; 2002. P . 513.
|
| 3. | Kashyapa Samhita with Vidyatini. Bhishagacharya S, editor. 5 th ed. Khilasthana. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2002. p. 260.
|
| 4. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Sutrasthan Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 181.
|
| 5. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Sutrastahna, Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 120.
|
| 6. | Sushruta Samhita with Nibandhasangraha. Commentary of Shri Dalhanacarya. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 7 th . Uttarsthana. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Orientalia; 2002. p. 814.
|
| 7. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Sutrasthan, Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 51.
|
| 8. | Ashtang Sangraha with Shashilekha Sanskrita. Commentary by Indu. Sharma SP, editor. 5 th ed. Chikitsasthana. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana;2006. P . 508.
|
| 9. | Ashtang Hridaya with the commentaries, Sarvangasundara of Arundatta and Ayurveda Rasayana of Hemadri. Sastri HS, editor. 9 th ed. Chikitsasthan. Paradakara Bhisagacarya. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Orientalia; 2002. p. 544.
|
| 10. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Sutrasthan, Varanasi: Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 52.
|
| 11. | Sharangdhar- Shangadharasanhita, commentary by Shri Prayagadatta Sharma, Notes by Shri Laxhmipati Tripathi. 5 th ed. Edited by Shri Dayashankara Pandeya, Purva khand, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 1976. p. 34.
|
| 12. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Vimansthan, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 238.
|
| 13. | Sushruta Samhita with Nibandhasangraha. Commentary of Shri Dalhanacarya. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 7 th ed. Sutrasthan. Varanasi: Chaukhamba Orientalia; 2002. p. 251.
|
| 14. | Charaka Samhita, Ayurveda Dipika Commentary of Cakrapanidatta. Jadavaji T Acarya, editor. 5 th ed. Sutrasthan, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthana; 2004. p. 52..
|
| 15. | Bhavaprakasha. Pandey G.S., Chunekar K.C., editors. Purva Khand: Chaukhambha; 2006. P . 129.
|
| 16. | Bhavaprakasha Nighantu. Purva Khand, Pandey GS, Chunekar KC, editors. Chaukhambha; 2006. p.12-3
|
[Figure 1]
[Table 1]
|
